· Desk editor: Ayesha Mirza · · Single source ·Updated

Supermarket porridge oats rated by food writer

A food writer has tasted and rated several supermarket brands of porridge oats in a recent test.

‘Bland, faintly sugary and cardboardy’: the best (and worst) supermarket porridge oats, tasted and rated
File photo ‘Bland, faintly sugary and cardboardy’: the best (and worst) supermarket porridge oats, tasted and rated Photo: The Guardian

Cooking methods vary widely

The tester cooked each brand using the recipe printed on its packet. Most jumbo oats required twice as much water as instructions suggested. Cooking times were often three times longer than recommended to achieve a creamy texture. Regular and vigorous stirring was essential for all products tested during this review.

Organic options taste better

Organic oats showed noticeably more flavour than conventionally grown varieties in the tasting panel. Texture depended mostly on whether flakes were cut or rolled whole. The best overall product was M&S organic traditional oats which scored five stars. It cooked for five minutes with 220ml water to create a velvety bowl.

Other brands also perform well

Mornflake Mighty oats offered a strong bargain at four and a half stars. This British whole rolled oat product came from a family mill in Crewe. Tesco organic oats held their shape while many other brands collapsed during cooking. Flahavan's organic porridge oats made a creamy dish where sweetness dominated the flavour.

Reported by one outlet

Only one outlet has published this. Nothing here has been checked against a second report, so read it as that outlet's account and follow the link below for the original.

Reported by

1 independent outlet. Headline as published. Links open the original report.