· Desk editor: Adam Whitmore · · Single source

Astronomers question if black holes or galaxies formed first

New observations from the James Webb Space Telescope challenge the standard model regarding whether supermassive black holes or galaxies appeared earlier in the universe.

Early universe findings defy expectations

Astronomers previously assumed large galaxies formed before their central black holes. Dying massive stars were thought to leave behind remnants that merged into giants over time. New findings from the James Webb Space Telescope reveal that huge black holes were present only a few hundred million years following the Big Bang. Certain items seem nearly as huge as the stars within their home galaxies, challenging standard mass ratios found in close-by systems.

Scientists propose alternative origins

Roberto Maiolino from the University of Cambridge measured one such black hole in Abell2744-QSO1 and found it holds most of the object's mass. He suggests these giants may have grown faster than usual or formed directly from collapsing gas clouds. Another possibility involves primordial black holes seeding the universe shortly after the Big Bang before stars existed. Joseph Silk from Johns Hopkins University notes that current samples include only tens of objects, requiring more data to determine if this is typical.

Complex interaction between hosts

Black holes and galaxies influence each other throughout their evolution rather than existing in isolation. A growing black hole can release energy that heats gas or triggers new star formation. In giant elliptical galaxies, extreme violence from black holes may have limited host growth while spirals like the Milky Way see stars dominate feedback. Answering which came first will require far more data from the telescope to confirm if oversize black holes are common.

Reported by one outlet

Only one outlet has published this. Nothing here has been checked against a second report, so read it as that outlet's account and follow the link below for the original.

Reported by

1 independent outlet. Headline as published. Links open the original report.