· Desk editor: Kamran Abbas · · 2 sources

Judge sets March retrial for Lindsay Clancy accused of killing three children

A Massachusetts judge scheduled a second trial for Lindsay Clancy in Plymouth on March 29 following a mistrial in her first murder case.

US judge sets March retrial for Lindsay Clancy, accused of killing her 3 children
File photo US judge sets March retrial for Lindsay Clancy, accused of killing her 3 children Photo: South China Morning Post

Retrial date set despite objections

Judge William Sullivan ordered the retrial to begin on March 29 at the Plymouth superior court. Prosecutors objected to this specific date because they requested a trial in May instead. The judge ruled that holding the new trial does not violate constitutional protections against double jeopardy. Clancy faces three counts of first-degree murder for killing her children at their Duxbury home in January 2023.

Jurors split on insanity defense

The initial jury could not reach a unanimous verdict after eleven members favored an acquittal based on insanity. Only one juror disagreed with the others regarding Clancy's criminal responsibility for the killings. Defense attorneys argued she suffered from severe mental illness and postpartum psychosis during the events. Lawyers claimed the judge should have investigated or removed the single juror who opposed the acquittal before declaring a mistrial.

Next court dates confirmed

Attorneys will return to court at 9am on December 30 to discuss trial logistics and security arrangements. A pretrial conference is scheduled for February 18 to prepare for the upcoming proceedings. Clancy admits to killing her three children yet insists on her mental illness without dispute. Prosecutors argue she planned the killings and understood what she was doing at the time.

All 2 outlets report consistently

No differences in figures, names or dates across these reports.

  • South China Morning Post
  • The Guardian

Reported by

2 independent outlets. Headlines as published. Links open the original report.