New theorem limits disagreement between quantum observers
Researchers from Universidad Politécnica de Madrid and New York University published a new mathematical study on quantum observer disagreement in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences on November 17, 2026.

Observers disagree within limits
Even when two observers begin with an identical description of a quantum system and apply the same probability rules, they may still reach different conclusions regarding outcome chances. María García Díaz and Giannicola Scarpa from Universidad Politécnica de Madrid worked with Adam Brandenburger of New York University to identify these conditions. Their findings show that classical records of measurement outcomes can eventually restore agreement between the parties involved. The study proves that a specific quantum condition called common certainty forces agreement only when measurements are compatible.
Model shows one-third versus two-thirds
According to the researchers model, Alice and Bob measure one portion of a three-part quantum system to estimate test probabilities. Alice's measurement distinguishes between possibilities removing coherence and giving her a one-third chance that a separate test returns yes. Bob's measurement retains coherence allowing his estimate of the probability of a yes result to reach two-thirds. Despite remaining compatible, this discrepancy endures because executing the measurements in any sequence yields identical probability results.
Measurement changes system state
A measurement can change the system state in a way that affects the probability observers are trying to calculate. The shared state combines two possibilities that can interfere known as quantum coherence before Alice performs her specific action. Every observer modifies the shared initial condition based solely on their personal result to generate distinct computations regarding mutual certainty. The mismatch occurs between Alice's measurement and the binary evaluation of the third component.
Reported by one outlet
Only one outlet has published this. Nothing here has been checked against a second report, so read it as that outlet's account and follow the link below for the original.
Reported by
1 independent outlet. Headline as published. Links open the original report.