Judge rules USDA secretary violated First Amendment with religious emails
A federal judge ruled Thursday that USDA Secretary Brooke Rollins likely violated the First Amendment by sending Christian holiday messages to agency staff.
Court finds official emails unconstitutional
U.S. District Court Judge Trina Thompson in San Francisco issued the ruling on Thursday regarding four specific holiday-related emails sent by Rollins. The messages contained Christian imagery and text about Jesus Christ, God, Christmas, and Easter but omitted holidays from other religions. Employees filed a lawsuit in May after receiving these communications from her official email account addressing roughly 100,000 workers.
Judge cites authority and policy
Thompson stated that Rollins used her position of authority to suggest Christianity was the shared faith of Department of Agriculture workers. The judge observed that staff members cannot practically refuse to read messages from their agency director, an action that might pressure them to conceal their personal beliefs. According to Thompson, the decision was based on a USDA workplace religious expression policy that Rollins personally adopted.
Future conduct must change
The ruling commands that Rollins must stop disseminating religious messages if a colleague asks her to do so. She may discuss her faith with interested colleagues or politely invite co-workers to religious events in appropriate conversations. The National Federation of Federal Employees and six USDA employees brought the suit challenging these communications.
All 2 outlets report consistently
No differences in figures, names or dates across these reports.
- The Hill
- The Guardian
Reported by
2 independent outlets. Headlines as published. Links open the original report.